How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

For homeowners, home insurance is a necessity. This insurance protects your home and your belongings from theft or damage, and almost all mortgage companies mandate that borrowers have home insurance coverage for the fair or full value of their property. Without proof of home insurance, many mortgage companies will not finance a real estate transaction.

Many homebuyers may not know what to look for when it comes to home insurance comparison. Are you looking to understand the cost of your quotes or get cheaper quotes? Maybe you want to better analyze the numbers from a home insurance comparison tool. At David Pope Insurance Services, LLC, we have compiled this guide to help you understand how to compare home insurance quotes so you can feel confident in your decision.

Jump To:

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

Homeowners Insurance Coverage

Homeowners insurance policies are highly customizable, but they also include standard elements that determine what costs are covered by the insurance provider. Some of the key areas covered may include:

1. Personal Liability for Injuries or Damage

Your home insurance’s liability coverage is intended to protect you from lawsuits filed by other people. This liability coverage includes your pets, which means if your dog bites a neighbor, your insurance provider may pay for the neighbor’s medical expenses. If someone is injured while on your property and they sue you, you may also be covered.

To obtain a significant amount of liability coverage at an affordable rate, you may want to consider an umbrella insurance policy.

2. Interior or Exterior Damage to the Home

The interior or exterior of your home can be damaged by covered disasters, such as hurricanes, fire, lightning or vandalism. In these situations, home insurance may cover the costs if your home needs repairs or needs to be completely rebuilt. Belongings like appliances, furniture and clothing may also be covered if destroyed by an insured disaster. To cover lost jewelry, you can obtain off-premises coverage.

How much your insurance company will reimburse you for interior or exterior damage to your home may be a limited amount. For example, if you have coverage for 70% of your amount of home insurance and your home is insured for $150,000, you may have coverage for $105,000 worth of belongings. If many of your possessions are high-priced items, such as designer clothes, fine jewelry or fine art, you may want to pay more for coverage of these belongings.

3. Rental Coverage During Home Repairs or Reconstruction

If you are ever forced to live out of your home temporarily due to home repairs or reconstruction, additional living expenses coverage may reimburse you for a hotel room or rent, restaurant meals and other costs you incur. Keep in mind that your policy will likely impose daily and total limits for what will be reimbursed while you are out of your home. If you want to increase these limits, you can pay more for coverage.

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

What Is Excluded From Most Policies?

Home insurance covers many scenarios where a loss could occur, but not all events will be covered. Typically, events that are excluded from most home insurance policies are natural disasters, acts of war and acts of nature not included under covered disasters. Common exclusions from home insurance include:

  • Earthquakes
  • Pools
  • Mudflows
  • Sinkholes
  • Trampolines
  • Identity theft
  • Flood damage
  • Intentional loss
  • Mold damage
  • Aggressive dog breeds
  • Business-related claims
  • Preventable loss due to poor maintenance

For many of these exclusions, you may be able to purchase additional or separate coverage to get the protection you need. For example, if you want protection in the event of a flood, you can obtain a separate flood insurance policy. You may also consider adding sewer and drain backup coverage.

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

While you may have coverage for certain dog breeds, others may be excluded if the risk for that breed is too high. If your dog is an excluded breed, you can purchase additional coverage. You may also want to purchase separate coverage for the other structures on your property, such as a shed or a freestanding garage. If you are concerned about identity theft, you can purchase identity recovery coverage for protection.

What Goes Into a Home Insurance Quote?

Insurance companies determine quotes by assessing risk. To accurately compare home insurance rates, you may want to know which factors influence your quotes. The following are some factors to keep in mind:

  • Credit history: In most states, one of the most significant factors in determining your home insurance quote is your credit history. Insurers may look at your payment history, length of credit history, outstanding debt, credit mix and how recently you’ve sought new credit. If you have excellent credit, you will likely pay less for home insurance than homeowners with poor or fair credit.
  • Claims history: The claims you filed while living in your previous home may follow you when you seek home insurance before moving into a new home. Insurers know there is a correlation between previous claims and the likelihood of future claims, and this claims history can impact the quotes you receive for home insurance.
  • Roof condition: The condition of your roof will also impact your home insurance quote. A new roof is preferable, as you are less likely to have roof losses. If you have an older roof, this could increase your home insurance quote.
  • Home construction and age: How your home was constructed and its age can also influence your home insurance quote. If your home was involved in previous claims, this could affect your rate. Homeowners with older homes tend to pay more for rebuilding costs when their home is destroyed or damaged.
  • Replacement costs: When you compare homeowners insurance rates, the cost of replacement for your home may influence your quote. Replacement cost does not refer to the home’s market value but instead refers to the amount of money needed to build exactly the same home in the same location.
  • Dog breed: While a dog of any breed can be aggressive or friendly, insurers may view some breeds as riskier than others. Breeds that may be excluded from your liability coverage include Rottweilers and pit bulls. Have the details about your dog ready when it’s time to discuss your coverage needs with an insurance agent, such as the breed and your dog’s history.
  • Hot tub or pool: Though a hot tub or swimming pool can be nice amenities to have on your property, they can also increase your liability. As such, you will need more liability coverage to protect yourself in the event that someone is injured on your property.
  • Insurance score: Another factor that can have a significant impact on your home insurance quote is your insurance score. If you have a low insurance score, this can make an insurer view you as a financial risk. To improve your score, carry a modest credit card balance and avoid tax liens, bankruptcy, court judgment or having debt in default.
  • Marital status: Being married may work in your favor when it comes to getting a home insurance quote. Historically, married couples file fewer claims, and as a result, may be viewed as less of a risk by insurers.
  • Proximity to body of water: If your home is located near a body of water, this could raise your risk of flooding. If you live near a coastline, your risk of home damage due to hurricanes could also be higher. As standard homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, you may want to consider purchasing a separate flood insurance policy.
  • Proximity to fire department: If you live close to a fire department or to fire hydrants, you may pay less for homeowners insurance, as this can keep your home safer in the event of a fire.
  • Wood-burning stove: While a wood-burning stove can reduce your energy costs and add a nice aesthetic or aroma to your home, it can also increase your home insurance costs. To reduce your rate, inform your insurance agent if you have an easily accessible fire extinguisher nearby, keep smoke detectors close to the stove and ensure your stove meets code requirements.

With so many factors contributing to a home insurance quote, shopping around for the right policy can be a good option if you’re trying to save money. Reference the considerations above as you compare home insurance costs. Remember that while a good rate quote is excellent, you’ll also want coverage that adequately suits your lifestyle and needs and quality customer service.

6 Tips for Comparing Insurers for Home Insurance

Although shopping around for home insurance quotes can feel time-consuming, it’s beneficial in the long run. Searching for the policy that best fits your unique coverage needs can help you save a significant amount of money by not over- or under-insuring your home. To compare home insurance plans and insurers, you may want to look into the agencies, review current policyholder satisfaction and talk to a real person at the company:

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

1. Look Into the Agencies

First, you want to make sure the agencies are legitimate and worth your time. You can check the health of home insurance companies by considering the scores available on the websites of top credit agencies. Look for customer feedback and consumer complaints that may have been made against these companies. You may also want to know how a company processes claims.

Before you choose to work with an insurance company, you may also want to consider the insurer’s claims response. How long will you be in a difficult financial position if you suffer a large loss that you need to pay for out-of-pocket while you wait for reimbursement? Prior to purchasing a policy from an insurer, you may want to find out who will be receiving and handling claims calls.

2. Review Each Insurance Company’s Current Policyholder Satisfaction

When you compare homeowners insurance rates and companies, your next step is reviewing current policyholder satisfaction. Though every insurer will say it provides good claims service, you may want to ask an insurance agent about the company’s retention rate. This is the percentage of policyholders who renew their policies with the company each year.

Additionally, you can find information about policyholder satisfaction in online reviews, testimonials and annual reports. If you have friends or family with policies at an insurance company, you can ask them about their satisfaction with the insurer.

3. Talk to a Real Person

Often, the best way to get the most accurate quote and gather more information about an insurance company is to speak directly to an insurance agent who works with several insurers. These agents tend to be more transparent than captive agents who work for a single insurance company. At David Pope Insurance, we provide exceptional customer service and can answer your questions about the right home insurance policy for you.

4. Compare Quotes Based on Coverage

Home insurance companies may use different factors when determining a quote and charge different rates for varying coverage amounts. If possible, compare policies that offer the same amount of coverage. Comparing policies by coverage rather than price will help you tell which insurance company charges the most affordable rates for what you need.

It’s vital to remember that the cheapest isn’t always the best — a surprisingly low-cost policy may not offer the coverage you need. The best insurance policy is one that fully covers your home and belongings.

5. Check Third-Party Ratings

Policyholder satisfaction can tell you about an insurer’s customer service and whether their coverage fits policyholders’ needs. However, those considerations are only part of the larger picture. It’s also beneficial to check an insurer’s third-party ratings for financial strength. An insurer’s financial stability is essential for people considering homeowners insurance.

Insurance companies receive ratings from third parties like Standard & Poor’s (S&P) and AM Best. These third parties determine an insurance company’s financial stability by calculating:

  • Its ability to pay policyholders after a claim.
  • How likely it is to go out of business.

You may be able to find these ratings on an insurance company’s website.

6. Look for Discounts

Most insurance companies offer some form of discount for home insurance. For example, many insurers allow homeowners to bundle their home and auto insurance for a lower monthly rate. You may also be able to save if you pay your annual premium in full or install a home security system. Discounts vary between insurers, so check with each to see what they offer and whether you qualify.

Homeowners Insurance Policy Options

Home insurance comes in several policy forms. Some policy options provide more coverage than others, which is why it’s important for homeowners to know the difference. Though details tend to differ by company and state, the following are the standard homeowners insurance policy options:

1. HO-3 Insurance Policy

An HO-3 insurance policy is also referred to as a special form policy. This type of policy is the most common. If you are a homeowner with a mortgage, your lender likely requires that you obtain at least this level of home insurance coverage.

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

Under an HO-3 insurance policy, damage to your home will typically be covered from any cause other than those specifically excluded from your policy, like a flood or earthquake. Unless you purchase additional coverage, your belongings will likely only be covered from the following named perils:

  • Fire
  • Theft
  • Hail
  • Riots
  • Smoke
  • Lightning
  • Windstorms
  • Explosions
  • Vandalism
  • Falling objects
  • Volcanic eruptions
  • Damage from aircraft
  • Weight of snow, sleet or ice
  • Damage as a result of vehicles
  • Freezing of a household system
  • Sudden damage due to a power surge
  • Discharge or overflow of water from a household system, such as air conditioning, plumbing or appliances
  • Sudden bulging, cracking or tearing of a steam system, hot water system, fire protection system or air conditioning

2. HO-1 and HO-2 Insurance Policies

Less popular policy options are HO-1 and HO-2 home insurance policies. These policies only cover damage that was caused by an issue listed. Under an HO-2 insurance policy, your house and belongings typically will be covered only if damaged by the perils listed above. HO-1 insurance policies are less widely available and are the most basic home insurance policy types. This policy type covers even fewer perils than an HO-2 policy.

3. HO-5 Insurance Policy

HO-5 insurance policies are also referred to as premier coverage or comprehensive form coverage. These policies provide the broadest home insurance coverage. Besides the causes that are specifically excluded, this policy typically covers the damages from all causes. Not all insurance companies offer this policy option, and it is generally only available for homes that are well-maintained and located in low-risk areas.

Keep in mind that HO-3 policies are sometimes labeled as “premier,” but they don’t offer the broad coverage found in an HO-5 policy. Speak to your insurance agent if you want an HO-5 insurance policy.

4. Additional Insurance Policy Types

In addition to the previously covered types, other homeowners insurance policy types include:

  • HO-4 insurance policy: This home insurance policy type is for renters.
  • HO-6 insurance policy: This policy type is for condominium owners.
  • HO-7 insurance policy: This home insurance policy type is for mobile homes.
  • HO-8 insurance policy: This rarely used policy type provides limited home insurance coverage for older homes.

How much home insurance you will need depends on how much it will cost to rebuild your home if it gets destroyed. When you set the dwelling coverage limit for your home insurance policy at the cost of rebuilding, you can rest assured you will have enough coverage for repairs and you also won’t be paying for coverage you don’t need.

To calculate your estimated rebuilding cost, you can multiply the square footage of your house by the costs of local construction per square foot. Your insurer or insurance agent may be able to help you estimate the cost of home replacement. To determine how much coverage you need for your personal property, you may want to take an inventory of your belongings.

How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

Additional Home Insurance Coverage Options

As you compare home insurance costs, you may find that you want to add to your coverage beyond the most common policy options. Many insurance companies offer a range of add-ons and separate policies that plug gaps in coverage. Here are a few to consider:

  • Flood insurance: Adding this coverage protects your home and belongings in case of flood damage.
  • Earthquake insurance: Buying earthquake insurance might be a good idea if your home is in parts of the country prone to these natural disasters.
  • Personal cyber insurance: Some insurance companies offer coverage add-ons to help homeowners recover from cybersecurity attacks and online fraud.
  • Replacement cost coverage: Many home insurance policies cover the actual cost of homeowners’ belongings, which can be significantly lower than the replacement cost due to depreciation. Upgrading your policy to cover replacement costs can help you replace your damaged items with new ones.
  • Water backup: Water backup coverage helps with damage from backed-up sump pumps, drains or sewers.
  • Legal protection: This home insurance option covers a range of home-related legal costs you might incur, including inheritance and disputes with neighbors.
  • Accidental damage: If you want coverage for mishaps that standard insurance doesn’t cover — like a stray baseball flying through your window or a DIY project gone wrong — accidental damage insurance covers the costs.
  • Away-from-home insurance: If your possessions are damaged or stolen while you’re away, away-from-home insurance can cover the cost of their replacement.
  • Home emergency coverage: Home emergency coverage helps if you need insurance for heating or plumbing issues.
  • Bicycle insurance: Whether you have a valuable bike or use it as your sole means of transportation, bicycle insurance covers theft and repairs.

What Information Do You Need to Get a Homeowners Insurance Quote?

If you want a home insurance quote, you may need to provide the following information:

  • Who lives in your home
  • When your home was built
  • Your home’s square footage
  • Your home insurance history
  • What you need for liability coverage
  • Whether you have a dog and its breed
  • If you have safety devices for your home
  • When major renovations and improvements were made
  • Details about any home insurance claims you have made in recent years
  • Construction details about your home, such as the building type and age of your roof
How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

How Much Does Home Insurance Cost?

On average, home insurance costs a few thousand dollars every year. This figure considers factors including:

  • Your house’s age.
  • The materials that make up your home.
  • The estimated cost of rebuilding your home.
  • Your location.
  • Your area’s claims history.
  • Your personal claims history.
  • Your area’s fire rating.
  • Your coverage amount and any policy limits.
  • Your credit if you live outside of Maryland, Massachusetts and California.

The following are additional considerations that determine your home insurance costs:

  • Home-based business: If you have a home-based business, you may want to purchase an endorsement on a home insurance policy or an in-home business policy. An endorsement could increase your insurance costs, but will also protect the time and money you have invested in your business. An in-home business policy may also cover your lost income and your ongoing expenses if your business needs to close due to damages to your home.
  • Home liability limits: One of the most important factors in home insurance costs is the amount of coverage you obtain. To adequately protect yourself against a lawsuit, you may want to consider purchasing more liability coverage. If you have significant assets, an umbrella policy may be the best option for you.
  • Deductible: Your deductible is the amount of money you will pay to cover a loss before your insurer pays a claim. The higher your deductible is, the less you will pay for a home insurance premium.
  • Remodeling: Remodeling a part of your home can raise the property’s value, and this increased value may be reflected in a home insurance policy. The more expensive it is to rebuild the home, the more your home insurance may cost.
  • Location: Homeowners who live along the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, for example, tend to pay more for home insurance because of the frequency of severe storms. If you live in a riskier area, such as a flood zone, you may pay more for insurance.

How to Get Discounted or Free Quotes

When determining how to calculate home insurance costs, it’s important to note that just getting a quote could be one of the first expenses. Luckily, there are ways around that. Here are a few tips for getting a discounted or free home insurance quote:

  • Look online: Many insurance companies offer free quotes online. Search the insurance company’s website to determine whether they have a quote calculator tool. You may also be able to use a quote comparison website that uses your information to display a range of quotes.
  • Call or meet with an insurance agent: You can talk to an insurance agent over the phone or in person. Talk with an independent agent to find the lowest rates for the coverage you need. Unlike “captive” agents, independent agents can compare quotes from multiple insurance companies to find you the best.

How to Compare Home Insurance QuotesCost-Cutting Insurance Tips

You may be able to cut costs from your home insurance by following these tips:

  • Ask about other discounts: Insurance companies may be able to find you additional discounts.
  • Establish and maintain a solid credit history: Most insurance companies will be able to offer you better rates if your credit score is good.
  • Enhance the security of your home: Installing burglar alarms, smoke detectors and locks might earn you a discount.
  • Improve your home’s disaster resistance: Investing in storm-resistant windows or other structural upgrades could earn you a discounted rate.
  • Increase your deductible: You can significantly reduce your monthly premium if you’re willing to pay more out of pocket when you file a claim.
  • Purchase auto and home insurance policies from the same insurance company: Bundling multiple insurance types is an excellent way to save.
  • Remain with the same insurance company: Insurance companies frequently reduce premiums if policyholders stay for multiple years.
  • Review your home’s value and coverage: Reassessing the value of your possessions and the limits of your insurance policy every year ensures that you always have adequate coverage without overpaying.
  • Get quotes from multiple insurers: Comparing home insurance costs helps you find the lowest rate.
  • Build your no-claims bonus: Some insurance companies offer discounts the longer you continue with them without any claims on your insurance.
  • Pay your premiums annually: Paying the entire year’s premiums all at once can knock off the interest or additional administration fees.
How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes

Speak With David Pope Insurance Services, LLC

At David Pope Insurance, we offer our clients financial stability by finding the lowest rates for homeowners insurance available on the market. With more than 20 years of experience and 15 years in the business, our insurance firm is local and family-owned. We provide Missouri residents with the following types of insurance:

If you want to obtain insurance that will give you peace of mind while also keeping your costs low, we can provide the liability coverage you need to protect your assets. When you choose David Pope Insurance, we’ll provide a fast, flexible quote that is customized for your specific insurance needs. Let us know about your unique situation, and we can help you find the right coverage for the best premium possible.

Request a free quote for home insurance in Missouri or contact us at David Pope Insurance today.

Learn More About Home Costs

icon-angle icon-bars icon-times