Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Many people only think about insurance once they need to use it. However, you might be paying more than necessary for the coverage you’re receiving. Insurance rates have continued to increase over time. Experts estimate that car insurance rates will increase by 8% in 2023 alone.

Luckily, higher rates don’t necessarily mean you have to pay too much for car insurance. Regularly checking your coverage, knowing what factors affect the premiums you pay and adjusting your policies will help you avoid excessive costs.

Jump To:

Insurance Rates Factors: What Affects Your Rates?

A variety of factors affect how much you pay for home insurance or auto insurance. Some of these are beyond your control, while others you can adjust or correct as needed. Understanding everything that comprises your insurance cost of your insurance will help make you a better-informed consumer. Knowing what influences your rates can also help you as you shop around for a new insurance policy.

1. Gender and Age

Although you can’t receive preferential treatment based on your gender or age in many areas of life, insurance isn’t one of them. Insurers, particularly those offering car insurance, can adjust your rate based on how old you are or your gender, at least in some states.

Here are some ways that gender and age can impact your insurance costs:

  • Gender: Women typically pay less for auto insurance than men, especially young women. Statistically, younger women are less likely to get into accidents or to drive recklessly compared to younger men. Women under the age of 25 are likely to have lower insurance rates than men. However, some studies have found that older women, especially those between the ages of 30 and 60, often end up paying more for insurance.
  • Age: Age also influences how much you pay for auto insurance. Usually, older drivers pay less for insurance compared to those under the age of 25. However, senior drivers over the age of 70 may see increased rates.
  • Marital status: Another factor related to gender and age that affects your insurance premium is your marital status. Typically, you’re likely to notice a drop in your insurance costs if you change your status with your insurance company from single to married. From a statistical point of view, married drivers are often safer on the road than unmarried ones, so they have fewer accidents.

2. Experience and Record

Your driving history also impacts your insurance rates. If you drive recklessly or have a history of many speeding tickets or accidents, your insurance premiums should be higher than someone who has a clean driving record.

The number of years you’ve driven also affects your insurance. If you’re new to being behind the wheel, your driving record is relatively untested. An insurance company is taking a more significant chance on you compared to someone who has driven for years without so much as a speeding ticket or getting into a fender bender. The longer your driving record, the lower your insurance rates can become.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

The same is true of how long you’ve been driving. If you’re new to being behind the wheel, your driving record is relatively untested. An insurance company is taking a more significant chance on you compared to someone who’s been driving for years, without so much as a speeding ticket or fender bender.

Another factor influencing your insurance rates is why and how often you use your car. If you drive for work, you might have to pay a higher premium compared to someone who only drives for personal reasons or who rarely gets behind the wheel.

3. Claim History

The goal of having insurance is to have protection if you get into an accident. The more you need to use your insurance protection, the more you cost insurance companies. Policy providers typically see people with a significant claim history as being a higher risk compared to people with few or no claims. That’s one of the reasons your insurance premiums typically rise after you have a car accident or otherwise need to use your insurance coverage.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Your claim history also influences the rates you pay for home insurance. Any claims filed on the home during the past seven years go into the Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (CLUE) database. Insurers look at a home’s or car’s CLUE report to see if there has been a history of claims and to get a better sense of what those claims were.

While you can’t change your past, you can take steps to minimize future claim numbers. In turn, you can keep your rates lower.

4. Credit History

Your credit score does much more than determine whether you’re eligible for a loan or the interest rate a lender will offer you. It can also influence your insurance premiums, particularly for car insurance. Insurers typically use a unique calculation of your credit score when assessing your eligibility and rate. It’s not the same score a lender uses when approving you for a loan. That said, many of the same factors, such as your payment history and the amount of debt you have, go into determining your car insurance credit score.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

If you’re concerned about how your credit history affects your insurance rates, focus on reducing your total debt amount, stay updated on your payments and bring down your credit use ratio.

5. Location and Conditions

Your location also affects home and car insurance. In the case of home insurance, you will likely pay more for your premiums in an area with a higher-than-average number of natural disasters. If you live in an area that experiences flooding, you’ll most likely need to pay extra to purchase flood insurance, for example.

Living in a city or densely populated area can mean higher car insurance rates. A large city can mean a greater number of cars and a higher risk of a collision or another accident. Some areas also have higher rates of theft, which can drive up your insurance rates for homes and cars. One way to lower these rates is to purchase anti-theft tools, such as a car alarm or home security system.

Your home’s condition also influences your rates. Recently built homes are often less expensive to insure compared to older ones. In addition, homes often cost less when they consist of more durable materials like brick.

6. Vehicle Type

Your vehicle type can also impact your car insurance costs. For instance, providers will consider factors like:

  • Make and model: Different car models vary by safety features and ratings. A car’s safety rating evaluates how it performs in accidents or other dangerous situations. The higher the score, the safer the vehicle is to drive. Some insurance companies prefer to insure vehicles with strong safety ratings, which can decrease your rates. In addition, you might encounter lower rates for vehicles with trusted makes or styles. Sports cars and other high-performance vehicles tend to have higher rates.
  • Age: Your car’s age can also affect your overall insurance expenses. For instance, newer cars might cost more to insure because of the car’s higher value. 
  • Average repair costs: Your car’s estimated repair costs also play a role in insurance amounts. The higher your repair costs, the more the insurance provider might have to pay. Newer vehicles can also have more expensive repair costs, which can raise your insurance premiums.

7. Average Vehicle Use

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Another factor influencing your insurance rates is why and how often you use your car. The more often you drive, the more opportunities you have to get into accidents. If you drive for work, you might have to pay a higher premium compared to someone who only drives for personal reasons or who rarely gets behind the wheel.

Insurance providers typically ask for annual mileage while they process your claim. That way, they can assess your average usage and adjust your claim as needed.

What Can You Do to Avoid Overpaying for Insurance?

No one wants to pay more than necessary for their insurance. While you can’t control some of the factors that affect your rates, like your age or gender, you can use various methods to avoid paying too much for insurance. If a lot of time has passed since you viewed your insurance rate or browsed for a new policy, you might realize you’re overpaying for car insurance coverage you don’t need. Additionally, major life changes can impact your policy costs. For instance, getting married or turning 25 can affect your premiums. It’s always best to monitor your insurance policies to make sure you’re not paying too much.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

How To Find Out If You’re Overpaying For Insurance

It’s a good idea to check in on your insurance from time to time to make sure it still meets your needs. If many years have passed since you last looked at your insurance policies, you might be paying for coverage you don’t need.

Here are some strategies for how to not overpay for car insurance:

Review Your Coverage

If you’re driving an older car, you might not need to insure it for as much as you did when the car was new or when you were still paying off your car loan. You may find you can benefit from less coverage and a lower premium.

Assess Your Deductible

Alternatively, you might discover you have a low deductible and that switching to a policy with a higher deductible helps you save a considerable amount. A higher deductible will mean you need to pay more out of pocket if there’s a problem with your home or car, but it also means you spend less upfront.

Ask About Discounts

It’s also worthwhile to check to see if you’re eligible for discounts on your insurance premium. Many auto insurance policies offer discounts, ranging from a reduced premium for drivers who haven’t had a claim in several years to lowered premiums for people who complete a driver’s education course. Bundling insurance policies, such as combining your home and auto insurance, can help reduce your rate, too.

Consider the Factors Affecting Your Premium

You might also want to ask about the factors that are affecting your premiums. If you’re driving a small, older car and paying a lot to insure the vehicle, it might be financially worthwhile to purchase a newer car or upgrade to a larger vehicle with more safety features.

Ask Your Broker to Provide Rates From Other Companies

It pays to shop around when it comes to insurance, but many people don’t do so. They buy a policy when they become homeowners or when they first get their car, and they keep it until they move or get a new vehicle. If it’s been some time since you looked at policies, it’s a good idea to ask your insurance broker to show you what’s available. An insurance broker works with you to help you find the best policy at the best rate. They don’t represent one single insurance company,  meaning they are working for you to identify a policy that is in your best interests and that matches your current needs.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Perhaps you’ve been overpaying for your auto insurance and your current policy no longer meets your needs. The same is true for your home insurance. With the support of an insurance broker, you can pick a policy that provides the coverage you need for a lower overall premium.

Check Average Insurance Costs in the Area

It’s also a good idea to browse average insurance costs are for your city, town or neighborhood you live in. Location matters when it comes to insurance premiums for car and home insurance. Areas with low rates of crime are likely to have lower premiums compared to areas with high theft rates. The same is true for areas that experience extreme weather events, compared to ones that don’t.

Request a Free Homeowners Insurance Quote

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Along with getting a sense of the average cost of insurance in your area, it’s worthwhile to research how you can do to reduce that cost. For example, if you live in a city and own a car, you might get a discount on your insurance premium if you pay to park your car in a garage or other secure parking area, rather than parking it on the street. In the case of home insurance, your premiums might drop if you invest in storm-resistant roofing materials, storm shutters or other improvements that can protect your home from damage due to a natural disaster.

If you currently live in an area with higher-than-average insurance costs, it might make financial sense to relocate. Even a small change, such as moving to the next town over, might be enough to significantly lower your insurance premiums. Once you know what insurance costs are for the area, you can weigh the pros and cons of relocating.

How to Shop for Discounts

To shop for insurance discounts, it’s helpful to first understand which discounts providers commonly offer. Discounts you may be eligible for include:

  • Paperless discount: One discount many insurance providers offer is a paperless discount. When you choose to go paperless, you’ll receive your policy documents and billing statements electronically. Since the company saves money when they don’t have to send statements via snail mail, they can pass on the savings to you.
  • Multi-vehicle discount: Some insurance providers offer discounts for putting multiple vehicles on the same policy. If you have a partner or child or simply own more than one vehicle, you could save money by insuring them all under the same policy.
  • Good student discount: Being a good student can help you save money on auto insurance. This discount is typically available to students who have at least a B average.
  • Low-mileage discount: Your insurance provider may offer the chance to use a mobile app or plug-in device that tracks your mileage for a set period of time. Based on your mileage and safe driving habits, you may qualify for a discount.
  • Driver’s ed course discount: Your insurer may offer a discount for taking and passing a driver’s ed course. Schools sometimes offer these courses to teen drivers, but YMCAs and local community centers may also offer a program.

Ask your insurance provider about what discounts may be available to you to make sure you’re getting the most out of your policy for the most affordable price.

How to Decrease Insurance Costs

Besides discounts, there are a few other options you may have for lowering your insurance costs.

  • Buy the right car: One of the most important factors for the calculation of your insurance premium calculation is the type of car you drive. When you’re shopping for your next car, consider more than just the sticker price. The overall cost of ownership includes gas, maintenance and insurance costs. Typically, models that top the lists for safety are among the most affordable to insure, while luxury, sports and electric vehicles tend to be more expensive.
  • Pay in full: While you can pay your premium each month, if you pay in full annually or biannually, you could save money. If you can, put aside savings to pay your policy in one lump sum.
  • Choose a higher deductible: By choosing a higher deductible, you’ll save on your monthly premium. You may want to put your monthly savings away until you have enough to cover your deductible in the event that you need to file a claim.
  • Request rates before your child hits the road: Before your child gets their license, request insurance rates. You may want to add your child to your credit card so they can begin building their credit and get a lower rate in a few years.
  • Browse other rates once a year: Another technique for lowering insurance costs is exploring other insurance quotes regularly. You can compare quotes from various providers at least once a year to ensure you’re receiving the best rate possible. In addition, you should research quotes after significant life or driving changes occur. For instance, changing your marital status or receiving a speed ticket can impact your rates. By browsing all available quotes, you can keep your costs low.

Pursuing these strategies can help you to not overpay for car insurance.

Request a Free Auto Insurance Quote

Questions to Ask When Buying Insurance

Several questions for your insurance broker can help ensure you get the coverage you need at a price that works for you. When shopping for insurance, it’s essential to ask the following.

  • How much is the deductible? The deductible is the amount you chip in when you have an insurance claim. Usually, deductible amounts can range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars. The higher the deductible, the lower your premiums. If you have a good driving record and a clean claim history, choosing a policy with a higher deductible can help you save a considerable amount of money.
  • Can you combine home and auto policies? Many insurance companies allow you to bundle policies, resulting in a combined premium that’s lower than what you would pay for two separate policies.
  • How will _____ change my insurance? Life is full of changes. For example, your children might get their driver’s licenses and need you to add them to your auto insurance policy, or you might get married and want to add your spouse. When shopping for insurance, it helps to find out how life changes like these affect your insurance options. It’s also valuable to understand what insurance options are available to you as you go through life.
  • What types of insurance do I need? The types of insurance you need depends on where you live, the laws of your state and what you’re insuring. If you don’t own a home, but rent, you’ll want to consider renter’s insurance, for example. If you’re driving a leased vehicle or a car you’re still paying off, you’ll most likely need collision and liability insurance. Your broker can help you choose a policy with the appropriate amount of coverage.

When Did You Last Shop Around?

Insurance rates typically increase annually, but that doesn’t mean you are necessarily stuck paying higher and higher premiums as the years go on. If it has been several years since you last shopped for insurance, it can be a good idea to jump back in and shop around for a new policy.

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

Since time is money and it takes time to shop around for home, renter’s or auto insurance, it can be a good idea to work with an insurance broker. A broker will take your information — such as your age, marital status and gender — and details about your home and car and get several quotes from multiple insurance companies. They’ll show the quotes to you, explain what each one offers and its price and let you pick the policy that seems like the best fit for you.

Are You Paying for the Right Level of Car or Home Insurance?

There’s no need to pay extra for coverage you don’t need. At the same time, you also want to be sure your policy adequately covers your needs. If you’re wondering whether you’re overpaying for insurance, here are some aspects to consider:

  • What you use your home or car for: If you work from home, you may need to add an endorsement to your homeowners policy to protect your business, or you might need to purchase a separate business insurance policy. If you use your car to drive for a ride-hailing company or drive it for business purposes, you are going to need more coverage than the typical driver.
  • If you’ve made changes to your home: Remodeling or making other upgrades to your home can make it worth more, which can also mean that you need to purchase more coverage to protect it.
  • If you want more than the minimum coverage: Often, the minimum amount of insurance coverage required by your state isn’t enough to protect you from being sued, nor does it cover collision damage to your vehicle. It can be worthwhile to ask about umbrella policies and collision coverage if you want more substantial protection.
  • The age of your vehicle: The value of a new car starts to drop the minute you drive away from the dealership. If something happens to a new car, the amount an insurer pays out might not be enough to cover the replacement of the car or to pay off the loan on a newer vehicle. If you have a new car, it can make sense to buy gap coverage to make up the difference between the value of the car and the amount you might owe on the car loan.

David Pope Insurance Services, LLC Can Help You Avoid Paying Too Much for Insurance

Am I Overpaying for Insurance?

If it’s been a while since you shopped for car or home insurance in Missouri, David Pope Insurance is here to help you. Since 2005, many people in Union, St. Clair and Washington have made us their one-stop shop for all their insurance needs. We’ll listen to what you need and help you find an insurance policy that fits your budget, while providing the right amount of protection. Contact us today for quotes and to get started.

Contact David Pope Today

icon-angle icon-bars icon-times